Refine Search
Map
Sort by
$995,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 21460776 MLS
Some properties are purchased. This one is passed down. With 10.2 unrestricted acres and an incredible 1,150 feet of year-round deep water frontage, this is the kind of property families spend generations searching for. Whether your vision is a private estate, a family compound, vacation cabins, or simply keeping it exactly as it is, the multiple build sites give you room to dream without limits. The 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath home is perfectly positioned to soak in the water views, while the detached 2-car garage, private boat launch, and boat dock make lake life effortless. Spend your mornings casting a line, your afternoons swimming in deep water, and your evenings watching the sun disappear across the lake. Properties offering this much shoreline, usable acreage, unrestricted potential, and true year-round water are exceptionally rare. This isn't just a lake house—it's a legacy waiting for its next chapter.

15765 Highway 145, Shelby

Listing courtesy of A Squared Properties, LLC.

$650,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 21459833 MLS
Great location, even better lake views! This move-in ready home has been gorgeous updates throughout. With plenty of space for the whole crew-2 bedrooms and two baths on the main level plus a basement level den, bedroom and full bath. You'll love the open kitchen and living room. The large island, custom cabinets, stone fireplace, and built in bar make it easy to relax and kick back on game day. Just off the living room is a spacious sun room with perfect views of Lay Lake. The basement has its own den, bedroom and full bath and a two car garage. The two slip boat house with lifts has a great area to entertain or take it easy by the water. You'll love the convenience to I-65 and Highway 280, but you may never want to leave once you are here!

17030 Highway 42, Shelby

Listing courtesy of eXp Realty, LLC Central.

$415,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 21459673 MLS
Come enjoy lake living on beautiful Lay Lake/Spring Creek Area. This 3 bedroom 2 bath home features a functional layout with an open living/dining area, ideal for everyday living or weekend getaways. The split bedroom design offers privacy, while all the natural light creates a warm and inviting atmosphere. Outside, you'll find ample space for parking. There is a huge covered outdoor deck perfect for taking in the beautiful view. This beauty has tons of space!! The extra office/study is a bonus! There is a Beautiful rock seawall and the same rocks outline the entire driveway! The landscape lighting accents the beautiful rocks. There is also an existing sprinkler system. This home can be mortgaged & has a HUD compliant engineer certificate for the foundation. APCO has also previously approved a boathouse! Don't miss out on this one!!!!

4854 Highway 71, Shelby

Listing courtesy of EXIT Royal Realty.

$575,000
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 21459647 MLS
Discover the charm of this custom lake home nestled in a peaceful cove / slough within the beloved Shelby Shores Community. Beautiful pine ceilings, hickory cabinetry, solid-wood interior doors, Pella windows, and a new HVAC system with all new ductwork (02/2026) add quality and character throughout. Enjoy effortless Lay Lake days with a covered two-slip boathouse featuring two boat lifts, just a short, level walk from the home. With approximately 3 acres and spacious one-level living, there's room to relax, entertain, and make lasting memories. A rare opportunity to own a true lake retreat. Schedule your showing today and let's get you home before fall!

36/34 Pine Knoll Circle, Shelby

Listing courtesy of RealtySouth-I459 Southwest.

$299,997
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 21458035 MLS
Lay Lake- this one is now up for grabs! Located within walking distance from the well-known & loved Lacoosa Marina. Cherished three-bedroom, 1.5 bath home offers the perfect opportunity to enjoy lakefront living at an affordable price. Generations of Love & Care. For the past 32 yrs, this home has been deeply loved and meticulously maintained by a single owner. The pride of ownership shines through in every corner, most notably in the beautifully remodeled main bathroom, which now features a spacious, modern double shower. Comfortable and Accessible Lake Living. Designed for easy living, the home features a thoughtful mix of tile, laminate, carpet, and vinyl flooring throughout. Accessibility is easy w/double-covered parking & gently sloping ramp that leads directly to your relaxing covered porch, allowing you to completely bypass stairs. Includes a private two-slip dock to keep your watercraft protected plus 2 additional storage buildings.

51 Lay Lake Way, Shelby

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Metro South.

$550,000
21457092 MLS
What a beautiful piece of land and an opportunity to build your on paradise- You can choose to have a view of the water or the woods, or BOTH! These 20 acres are nestled in a gated community where you will enjoy privacy and still so close to downtown Columbiana. The pavilion, located right beside the water, is ready to use! Make an appointment to see the endless possibilities to make it what you have always dreamed of.

609 Black Horse Run Unit 20, Shelby

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Metro South.

$640,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 21455974 MLS
Lay Lake living at its BEST! Located in Shelby Shores community, this beautifully maintained waterfront home is ready for summer FUN. Featuring 4 bedrooms, 3 baths, including 2 primary suites w/private baths, this home offers plenty of space for family & guests. Inside you’ll find hardwood floors, living area with lake views, updated kitchen w/custom cabinetry & a large island perfect for gathering. The finished basement space is ideal for a craft room, bunk room or game room. Outside, enjoy everything that makes lake life special: large deck w/access from master or den, private boat ramp, concrete seawall, separate pier w/slide & impressive two-story boathouse with 2 lifts and a large upper sun deck overlooking the main channel. Need storage? The 30x30 powered detached garage is perfect for boats and lake toys. Plenty of parking spaces w/carport, garage and driveways. Rare opportunity to own a turnkey lake retreat in one of Lay Lakes favorite neighborhoods!

50 Bentley Circle, Shelby

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Advantage.

$475,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 21455652 MLS
Big Price Improvement. Now is the time to start Lake Living!! Enjoy beautiful main channel views from this move-in ready, 3bd/2ba home in the highly desirable Shelby Shores community on Lay Lake. This well-maintained home is ready for you to start enjoying lake life with fresh paint, new flooring and space for everyone. The floor plan includes a large family room with a cozy brick fireplace, kitchen with painted cabinets w/ breakfast area, dinning room, living room and a full basement providing plenty of room for storage, hobbies, or all your lake toys. The screened porch is the perfect place to enjoy your morning coffee, gather with friends, or simply relax and take in the peaceful lake views. Shelby Shores is known for its year-round neighborhood events & some of the best neighbors on Lay Lake. Excellent location, mature trees & beautiful main channel views, this property offers perfect setting for a full-time residence or weekend getaway.

55 Christa Circle, Shelby

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Advantage.

$899,000
4 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 21452280 MLS
Perched on one of the most breathtaking points on Waxahatchee Creek, “The Sunset Lodge” is a rare New England-style log home unlike anything else on the lake. Built with massive hand-hewn logs and authentic chinking, this extraordinary retreat offers over 4,700 sq ft plus 1,100+ sq ft of screened porches designed for unforgettable lake living. The soaring great room features vaulted ceilings, stone fireplace, wet bar, built-ins, and stunning sunset views through double French doors. Main level primary suite, oversized upstairs bedrooms, loft, and expansive lower level with den, fireplace, pool room, workshop, and guest suite provide space for gathering and relaxing. Enjoy boating, fishing, skiing, paddleboarding, birdwatching, and peaceful evenings overlooking what may be the best sunset view on the entire lake. A legacy property designed for generations of lake memories.

389 Ridge Drive, Shelby

Listing courtesy of Arcara Residential, LLC.

$725,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 21449672 MLS
Private Island with an Unmatched Magnificent Western Red Cedar Estate in Shelby Shores. A Fortuitous find with 500'+/- of Waterfront and is famously known as The Home of the 2007 $500K Bass. These Grounds are a Haven for local Deer & features a majestic "Witness Tree," a living piece of History standing guard over the Landscape. Inside, Home breathes Character with Hand-hewn Beams & Pine floors salvaged from Vintage Railroad Cars. The huge Fireplace is the heart of the home, with stone exposed soaring to the Second Level. Large Open Kitchen with Quartz (Sileston) Countertops, while the Main-level Master Suite offers a peaceful Retreat. With 4 Bedrooms & a Bonus Room, there is versatile use of space for Guests-All protected by a Generac Generator & driveway Alarm. The grounds are primarily natural. Enjoy a covered Lakeside Deck, Large Dock with a Boat Ramp with Impressive depth at the dock for Toons and Watercrafts.

18718 River Drive, Shelby

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Metro South.

$598,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 21433358 MLS
Escape to tranquility at this beautiful lakefront home, featuring serene views and a calm atmosphere. This property boasts a spacious front porch, along with upper and lower cover back decks that offer the perfect outdoor space for relaxation and entertainment. Enjoy evenings by the patio fireplace while soaking in the wonderful lake views. The home features beautiful hardwood floors throughout the main level with the kitchen being equipped with stainless steel appliances. It has the perfect layout with the main level offering a master suite, living room, laundry room and half bath with two additional bedrooms and bath on the second floor. The basement features a second fully equipped kitchen, living room, bedroom and bath making it perfect for entertaining. Stepping back outside the home has a drive that takes you to your own private covered boathouse and large pier. This is lakeside living at its finest. Don't miss out on the opportunity to make this your dream home!

358 Ridge Drive, Shelby

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Advantage.

$539,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 21410220 MLS
Escape to the beauty of lakefront living with this spacious 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home offering approximately 2,700 sq. ft. of comfort and breathtaking views. Nestled on the shores of Lay Lake, this property boasts lake access, a dock, and a large deck perfect for enjoying sunrises and sunsets over the water. Inside, the open-concept design showcases vaulted ceilings, large windows, and an inviting living room with a cozy fireplace.

250 L And M Trace, Shelby

Listing courtesy of Down South Realty Inc.

$750,000
6 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 21408456 MLS
Custom, Well-built, one of a kind rare find with almost 2 ac Lakefront lot just off Waxahatchee on Lay Lake. This home has it all and with many update and beautiful, stunning views. 3 bedrooms, with their own private baths, guest half bath, family rooms, office, dining room, huge laundry room with a pantry. 2x6's used instead of 2x4's in this build, 9 & 10' ceilings, refinished hardwood floors. In the basement there is a den, 3 bedrooms, 1 bath, workout room, workshop, garage and lots and lots of storage. A poured concrete block foundation, Covered patio out the basement, deck across the back of the house, and a front porch. Concrete driveway with plenty of parking for your guest and an area for overflow parking or boat trailers. There is a 2 stall boat house with 2 boat lifts and 165 ft of waterfront. You can tube, wakeboard & surf in the large/deep slew. Marina right around the corner with great food, gas & entertainment.

216 Mulberry Lane, Shelby

Listing courtesy of EXIT Royal Realty.